Thursday – Sunday from 4 PM · Elizabeth, IL

The Best Pizza in
Elizabeth, Illinois

Handcrafted 16-inch Napoletana & artisan pizzas.
From traditional classics to signature oak-smoked BBQ creations.
1336 Hwy 20, Elizabeth, IL.

4.8 Star Rated
Serving Pizza Thu–Sun • 4 PM to Close - Full BBQ Menu 7-Days a Week
Dine In · Take Out
Elizabeth & Galena Area
Eager Beaver BBQ artisan pizza — smoked brisket, ricotta, cherry tomatoes, and BBQ drizzle
#1
Pizza in
Elizabeth, IL
Elizabeth, Illinois

Pizza Worth the Drive.
Classics & Smokehouse Souls.

Whether you're craving a traditional Pepperoni & Sausage pie or want to try one of our signature oak-smoked BBQ creations, every pizza is built with real ingredients, hand-stretched dough, and zero shortcuts.

As Elizabeth's home for both traditional pizza favorites and low-and-slow smokehouse specialties, every pie is baked fresh to order for dine-in or takeout.

🍕

Traditional Classics & Bold BBQ Variety

Choose from classic favorites like Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, and Four Cheese, or dive into signature BBQ pies loaded with 12-hour smoked brisket and pulled pork.

🌾

Handcrafted 16-Inch Dough, Made Daily

No frozen crusts, no shortcuts. Hand-stretched 16-inch Napoletana dough made fresh to order every time.

🔥

Oak-Smoked Meats & Premium Toppings

Our brisket, pulled pork, and chicken are slow-smoked in-house overnight for our specialty pies, alongside top-tier cheeses and Italian meats.

The Lineup

Our Signature Pizzas

Traditional favorites done right, plus signature oak-smoked BBQ specialties you won't find anywhere else. Every pizza made fresh to order.

The Sloppy Brisket Beast Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ Elizabeth IL

The Sloppy Brisket Beast

Single Brisket: $33.75 | 2x Brisket: $41.75

House BBQ Moppin Sauce, Texas Style Brisket, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes, Fresno Peppers, Red Onions and Fried Onion Topper.

🔥 House Specialty
Hot Honey Hog Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ

Hot Honey Hog Pizza

$25.75

Pulled Pork, Hot Honey BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella, Ricotta, Red Onions & Pickled Jalapenos.

🍯 Hot Honey Heat
Lei That Beaver Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ

Lei That Beaver Pizza

$25.75

Lei That Beaver BBQ Sauce, Pineapple, Bacon & Pulled Pork.

🍍 Sweet & Smoky
Pickle Of A Pulled Pork Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ Elizabeth IL

Pickle Of A Pulled Pork Pizza

$26.25

House BBQ Moppin Sauce, Pulled Pork, Dill Pickle Slices, Mozzarella, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Red Onions & topped with Ranch.

🥒 Fan Favorite
Crazy Ranch Clucker Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ

Crazy Ranch Clucker

$28.00

Alfredo Sauce, Smoked Chicken, Bacon, Mozzarella, Whole Cherry Tomatoes, and topped with Ranch.

🌿 Chicken & Bacon
Build Your Own 16 Inch Napoletana Pizza — Eager Beaver BBQ Elizabeth IL

16" Custom Build-Your-Own

Base Cheese: $16.00

Start with a 16" cheese base with Marinara, BBQ, or Alfredo, and customize with your choice of meats, cheeses, veggies & garnishes.

🍕 Build Your Masterpiece

Custom 16" Napoletana Options

Our signature hand-tossed pizzas come in one size: a massive 16 inches. Build your own masterpiece!

Sauce Options

House Marinara · Choice of BBQ Sauce · Alfredo Sauce

Meats & Cheeses

Texas Brisket ($8.00) · Smoked Chicken ($3.75) · Pulled Pork ($3.75) · Bacon ($3.00) · Italian Sausage ($3.00) · Pepperoni Slices ($3.75) · Fresh Mozzarella Pearls ($4.25) · Feta Cheese ($3.75) · Ricotta Cheese ($3.00) · Sharp Cheddar ($2.00) · Extra Mozzarella ($2.75)

Veggies & Garnishes

Fresh Cherry Tomatoes ($2.25) · Roasted Garlic ($2.25) · Crimini Mushrooms ($2.00) · Black Olives ($1.75) · Fresno Peppers ($1.50) · Artichoke Hearts ($1.50) · Banana Peppers ($1.50) · Pineapple ($1.50) · Dill Pickle Slices ($1.50) · Fried Onion Topper ($1.50) · Red Onions ($1.50) · Pickled Jalapenos ($1.50) · House Ranch Drizzle ($1.50)

Order Pizza Online Now →
How We Make It

From the Smokehouse
to Your Table

Our pizza didn't come from a box or a franchise playbook. It came from years of perfecting low-and-slow BBQ — and asking: what if we put this on a pizza?

01

Dough Made Fresh Every Morning

Hand-made daily using quality flour and slow-risen for the right texture — crisp outside, airy and chewy inside.

02

Meats Smoked 12–14 Hours Overnight

Brisket, pulled pork, and chicken go into the smoker overnight. By the time you order, they've developed flavor for over half a day.

03

Hand-Stretched & Built to Order

Every pizza is hand-stretched when you order. No rollers, no press machines — just experience and care.

04

Baked to a Perfect Char

High heat, signature blistered crust. You'll know it when you see it — and taste the difference immediately.

Charred BBQ pizza crust — Eager Beaver BBQ Elizabeth IL
Smoked pulled pork pizza
BBQ sauce drizzle on pizza
Questions

Frequently
Asked

Everything you want to know about our pizza in Elizabeth, IL.

Yes! We serve all traditional pizza favorites — Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Four Cheese, Veggie, and Build-Your-Own custom pies, right alongside our signature oak-smoked BBQ specialty pizzas.

Pizza is served Thursday through Sunday starting at 4:00 PM until close. We make our 16-inch dough fresh every morning so every pie is baked fresh to order.

Absolutely. Order for dine-in, carry-out, or online. For large orders or catering, call us at 815-201-3855.

1336 US-20, Elizabeth, IL 61028 — right on Highway 20, a short drive from Galena, Stockton, and the surrounding Jo Daviess County area.

We combine traditional 16-inch Napoletana pizza craftsmanship with our authentic oak smokehouse. Whether you order a classic Pepperoni pie or an oak-smoked Brisket specialty, everything is made fresh from scratch.

Yes! Pizza is a fantastic option for parties and events. We offer full-service catering throughout Jo Daviess County. Learn about catering →

Come Find Us

Pizza in
Elizabeth, IL

📞
🕐

Pizza Hours

Thursday – Sunday: 4:00 PM – Close
Check Facebook for special updates.

🚗

Easy to Find

Right on Hwy 20 — serving Elizabeth, Galena, Stockton, Apple River, and all of Jo Daviess County.